fiction vs nonfiction blog post image

You may have been taught that the difference between fiction and nonfiction was as simple as the truth vs. made-up stories.

While writing “the truth” is perhaps the most important criteria for a work of nonfiction, some of the most talented writers know how to use elements from fictional writing to tell a true story in a riveting way. Likewise, many writers of fiction know how to draw inspiration from the real world and their own lives to make their stories relatable and compelling.

Understanding how the techniques of fiction and nonfiction can be used together will help you to better analyze the things you read, but also improve your own writing across genres.

What Is Fiction?

Simply put, fiction comes from the author’s imagination. While it can include magic and make-believe, it’s not limited to what you’d find in a child’s wildest fantasies; a fictional story can take place in an ordinary world (even in a real town), with realistic characters and plot points that many of us have experienced ourselves.

Sometimes, fictional stories are based on real-life people, places, and events, but those things serve as inspiration for the narrative, which is fabricated by the author.

For example, Celeste Ng’s bestselling novel Little Fires Everywhere takes place in Shaker Heights, which is a real suburb in Ohio. Many of Stephen King’s novels are set in Derry, Maine—not a real place, but heavily inspired by King’s own hometown of Bangor. And Michael Punke’s The Revenant is based on the true 1823 story of a fur trapper who survived a bear attack after being abandoned by his companions.

So while fiction can take a lot of inspiration from real life, what really separates it from nonfiction is its use of narrative techniques such as imagery, pacing, and the temporary withholding of information to generate suspense.

In fiction, there are different characters whose motivations push the story along. And while you might refer to the real people described in nonfiction as “characters” in their own right, reading a biography of Abraham Lincoln is a very different experience from watching the 2012 film Lincoln.

Because although most of us know the basic facts about Lincoln and his life (including his untimely assassination), watching it unfold as a dramatic narrative still leaves us in suspense and fills us with emotion.

What Is Nonfiction?

Nonfiction, on the other hand, has to be 100% factual. Works of nonfiction report on real events, people, and places.

Examples of nonfiction writing include:

Whereas some truths in a work of fiction can actually serve the story by making it more compelling, just one fabrication is a work of nonfiction can destroy an author’s reputation and take away the story’s credibility.

Blurring the Lines

While the main difference between fiction vs. nonfiction is pretty straightforward—nonfiction has to be 100% factual—that doesn’t mean some of the same techniques can’t be applied to both types of writing.

Many types of nonfiction, such as memoirs, biographies, and journalistic reports, utilize narrative techniques to tell a true story.

These creative elements can include imagery, dialogue, narrative arcs, and scene-setting. You might also see some thorough character development. (Even though the “characters” must be completely real people and nothing about them or their actions can be fabricated, nonfiction authors can use creative methods, such as snippets of dialogue or scenes from real events, to reveal more about those key individuals.)

What do you call a book that is both fiction and nonfiction?

A nonfiction book technically can’t feature any fictitious content (as in events, people, and information that aren’t real or true)—but nonfiction that uses the elements of fictional writing (as described above) is often referred to as creative nonfiction.

Modern examples of creative nonfiction, which to date have not been challenged on their veracity, include memoirs like When Breath Becomes Air by Paul Kalanithi, and I’ll Be Gone in the Dark by true crime journalist Michelle McNamara. These books tell the true stories of the authors’ lives, but in the form of a narrative that reads like a story.

In 1966, author Truman Capote released a “non-fiction novel,” In Cold Blood, that was widely considered one of the greatest works of creative nonfiction. Capote spent 6 years writing the book, conducting extensive interviews and traveling on numerous occasions to the scene of the crime, which he detailed in rich and evocative detail throughout the book.

However, questions about its veracity, including claims of fabricated quotes and important details, resulted in criticism and ultimately his disqualification for a Pulitzer Prize.

When analyzing nonfiction, it’s always important to remember that you’re reading from one person’s perspective: the author’s. And since there are usually (at least) two sides to every story, it’s very possible that some people who were involved in the story, or who experienced similar circumstances, may not describe the experience in the same way.

That doesn’t necessarily mean that the author lied or fabricated details: it just means that was how things happened from the author’s unique point of view.

Understanding Fiction vs. Nonfiction

Although the lines may seem to blur between what’s fiction and what’s nonfiction, telling them apart is pretty simple, if you remember one key difference.

If a story reports the truth and nothing but the truth, it can be considered nonfiction. But if a story fabricates details or even stretches the truth, it should be treated as fiction.

Which do you prefer reading: fiction or nonfiction? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

 

If you enjoyed this post, then you might also like: